Why Methanol And Water Show Positive Deviation

We know that a mixture of ethanol and water shows a positive deviation from Raoult’s law. This means that the total vapor pressure of the solution is higher than what we’d expect from an ideal solution. The reason for this is that the intermolecular forces between ethanol and water molecules are weaker than the forces between ethanol molecules and water molecules.

Let’s break this down a bit further. Ethanol has a hydrogen bond with its own molecules (ethanol-ethanol) because of the -OH group. Water also has a hydrogen bond (water-water) for the same reason. However, when we mix them, the hydrogen bond between ethanol and water is weaker than the individual hydrogen bonds between ethanol and ethanol or water and water. This means that the ethanol and water molecules aren’t as strongly attracted to each other as they are to their own kind.

This weaker attraction between ethanol and water molecules means that they have a greater tendency to escape into the vapor phase, leading to a higher vapor pressure than an ideal solution would have. In other words, the ethanol and water molecules are more likely to “break free” from the liquid and become a gas.

Think of it like this: imagine you have two groups of people, each very close-knit and comfortable with each other. When you put these two groups together, they might not be as friendly with each other. They’d rather stick with their own group, and this “lack of friendliness” makes them more likely to go their separate ways. Similarly, ethanol and water molecules are more likely to vaporize when they’re mixed together because they don’t have the same strong attraction to each other that they have within their own groups.

Methanol, a highly polar molecule, readily forms hydrogen bonds with itself. These hydrogen bonds are strong intermolecular forces, contributing to methanol’s relatively high boiling point. When acetone is added to methanol, it disrupts these hydrogen bonds. Acetone, being less polar than methanol, has weaker intermolecular forces, mainly dipole-dipole interactions.

The disruption of the hydrogen bonds in methanol by acetone leads to weaker intermolecular forces in the solution. Weaker intermolecular forces result in a lower enthalpy of mixing, meaning less energy is released when the two liquids are mixed. This reduction in enthalpy contributes to a positive deviation from Raoult’s Law.

Let’s break down why this deviation happens:

Raoult’s Law: This law states that the vapor pressure of a solution is proportional to the mole fraction of each component in the solution. It assumes ideal solutions where the interactions between the components are similar to those within the pure components.

Positive Deviation: When a solution exhibits a positive deviation from Raoult’s Law, the vapor pressure of the solution is higher than what is predicted by the law. This indicates that the molecules in the solution are escaping into the vapor phase more easily than they would in an ideal solution.

In the case of methanol and acetone, the hydrogen bonds in methanol are stronger than the intermolecular forces between methanol and acetone. This means that the methanol molecules are more likely to escape from the solution into the vapor phase, resulting in a higher vapor pressure than predicted by Raoult’s Law.

The disruption of the strong hydrogen bonds in methanol by the presence of acetone leads to a weaker overall interaction between the molecules in the solution. As a result, the molecules are more likely to escape into the vapor phase, causing the observed positive deviation from Raoult’s Law.

Let’s explore why some solutions exhibit positive deviation.

Positive deviation occurs when the interactions between the molecules of the two components (let’s call them A and B) in a solution are weaker than the interactions between the molecules of each component in their pure states. In simpler terms, A and B molecules “prefer” to hang out with their own kind rather than mixing with each other. This preference leads to a higher tendency for A and B molecules to escape the solution and enter their pure liquid states.

Imagine a scenario where A and B molecules are like two groups of people who don’t quite get along. In a solution, they’re forced to mingle, but they’d rather be with their own group. This disharmony leads to a less stable solution compared to when they are separate, resulting in positive deviation.

Here’s a more detailed explanation:

Weaker A-B interactions: When the attraction between A and B molecules is weaker than the attraction between A and A or B and B molecules, the solution becomes less stable. The molecules tend to break away from the solution and exist as separate liquids.
Vapor pressure: This preference for separation leads to a higher vapor pressure in the solution compared to what we’d expect based on the ideal solution behavior. Essentially, the molecules are more eager to escape the solution and become part of the vapor phase.
Boiling point: As a result of the higher vapor pressure, the solution’s boiling point will be lower than expected. The weaker A-B interactions make it easier for the molecules to transition into the vapor phase.
Enthalpy of mixing: The enthalpy change associated with mixing A and B, known as the enthalpy of mixing, will be positive in cases of positive deviation. This positive enthalpy indicates that energy is required to overcome the stronger A-A and B-B interactions to form the solution.

Examples of solutions exhibiting positive deviation include:

Ethanol and Hexane: Ethanol molecules form hydrogen bonds with each other, while hexane molecules primarily experience Van der Waals forces. The weaker interactions between ethanol and hexane lead to positive deviation.
Acetone and Water: While both components are polar, the hydrogen bonding in water is stronger than the dipole-dipole interactions between acetone molecules. This difference leads to a preference for the molecules to remain in their pure states, resulting in positive deviation.

Understanding the concept of positive deviation helps us analyze and predict the behavior of solutions. It provides insights into the interactions between molecules and how these interactions influence the properties of solutions.

Let’s talk about the interesting interaction between water and methanol. You might be wondering if their mixture shows positive deviation from Raoult’s law.

It’s true that water and methanol have different strengths of hydrogen bonding. Water molecules, with their two lone pairs of electrons, can form a robust network of hydrogen bonds. Methanol, on the other hand, only has one lone pair, limiting the extent of its hydrogen bonding.

The strength of hydrogen bonding between water and methanol is somewhere in between the strength of the bonding between water molecules and the bonding between methanol molecules. However, this doesn’t mean that their mixture automatically exhibits positive deviation. To understand why, let’s delve a bit deeper.

Positive deviation occurs when the interactions between the different molecules (in this case, water and methanol) are weaker than the interactions between the molecules of the same type. In other words, the water-methanol interaction is weaker than the water-water or the methanol-methanol interaction.

This can be explained by considering the overall interactions in the mixture. If the A-A (water-water) and B-B (methanol-methanol) interactions are stronger than the A-B (water-methanol) interactions, the solution will show positive deviation. This is because the molecules would rather interact with themselves than with the other type of molecule, leading to a tendency to escape into the vapor phase more readily.

In the case of water and methanol, the hydrogen bonding between water molecules is indeed stronger than that between methanol molecules. However, it’s crucial to remember that these interactions are not isolated. The interactions between water and methanol are also significant.

The extent of these interactions depends on several factors, including the relative concentrations of water and methanol. In some cases, the A-B interaction might be strong enough to counteract the difference in hydrogen bonding strength between water and methanol, leading to a more ideal behavior, or even a negative deviation from Raoult’s law.

To determine whether a specific mixture of water and methanol shows positive deviation, experimental data is required. We need to analyze the vapor pressures of the mixture at different compositions and compare them to the predicted values based on Raoult’s law. This comparison will reveal whether the mixture exhibits positive deviation or not.

Let’s break down why a methanol and water solution isn’t considered an ideal solution.

While methanol and water can mix readily, they don’t form an ideal solution because their enthalpy of mixing isn’t zero. This means that when you mix methanol and water, heat is released, making the solution feel warm. This heat release indicates that the interactions between methanol and water molecules are different from the interactions between methanol molecules and water molecules alone.

Here’s a deeper dive into why methanol and water aren’t ideal:

Ideal solutions are defined by the absence of any heat change during mixing (enthalpy of mixing is zero). In an ideal solution, the molecules of the different components interact with each other in the same way as they do with themselves. This means there’s no change in energy when the components mix.
Methanol and water, however, exhibit non-ideal behavior because of the different strengths of the intermolecular forces involved. Water molecules strongly interact through hydrogen bonding. Methanol also forms hydrogen bonds, but they’re weaker than those in water.
When you mix methanol and water, the formation of new hydrogen bonds between methanol and water molecules releases energy, making the solution warm. This energy release is a sign that the interaction between methanol and water molecules is stronger than the interaction between the individual components.

So, while methanol and water can mix, their interactions are different enough that they don’t form an ideal solution. This difference in interaction strength results in the release of heat upon mixing, making the solution feel warm.

Let’s explore why a mixture of ethanol and acetone exhibits positive deviation from Raoult’s law.

In pure ethanol, the molecules are strongly attracted to each other through hydrogen bonding. This strong intermolecular force is responsible for ethanol’s relatively high boiling point. When acetone is added to ethanol, its molecules, which are less polar than ethanol, wedge themselves between the ethanol molecules, disrupting some of the hydrogen bonds. This disruption weakens the overall intermolecular forces within the solution.

The weakening of interactions leads to a decrease in the vapor pressure of the solution compared to what would be expected if the components behaved ideally according to Raoult’s law. This is because the weakened interactions make it easier for the molecules to escape into the vapor phase. The vapor pressure of the solution is higher than the ideal vapor pressure, resulting in positive deviation from Raoult’s law.

Think of it this way: Imagine ethanol molecules holding hands in a tight circle. Acetone comes along and breaks up the circle, weakening the grip each molecule has on the others. With less of a hold on each other, the ethanol molecules are more likely to escape the solution and become a gas.

Here’s a breakdown of why the disruption of hydrogen bonds leads to this phenomenon:

Hydrogen Bonding in Ethanol: Ethanol molecules form strong hydrogen bonds due to the presence of a hydroxyl group (-OH) in their structure. This strong attraction between ethanol molecules contributes to their high boiling point.
Acetone’s Intermolecular Forces: Acetone, on the other hand, has a carbonyl group (C=O) and lacks the ability to form strong hydrogen bonds. Instead, it primarily relies on weaker dipole-dipole interactions.
Disruption and Weakening: When acetone is added to ethanol, the less polar acetone molecules disrupt the hydrogen bonding network within the ethanol. These disruptions decrease the overall strength of the intermolecular forces in the solution.
Increased Volatility: The weaker intermolecular forces lead to increased volatility in the solution. This means the molecules are more likely to escape into the gas phase, resulting in a higher vapor pressure than predicted by Raoult’s law.

In essence, the presence of acetone in ethanol weakens the hydrogen bonds, making the solution more volatile and causing a positive deviation from Raoult’s law.

Let’s break down why benzene and methanol show a positive deviation from Raoult’s law.

Benzene disrupts the hydrogen bonding between methanol molecules. This disruption makes it easier for methanol to escape into the vapor phase, leading to an increase in evaporation and a decrease in the boiling point.

Essentially, the intermolecular forces between benzene and methanol are weaker than the forces within pure methanol. This weakening of attractive forces leads to a higher vapor pressure than predicted by Raoult’s law, resulting in a positive deviation.

Here’s a deeper dive into what’s happening:

Imagine methanol molecules, which are held together by strong hydrogen bonds. These bonds are like tiny magnets, attracting the molecules to each other and keeping them close.

Now, add benzene to the mix. Benzene doesn’t participate in hydrogen bonding. It’s like a non-magnetic substance that gets in the way of the methanol’s magnetic interactions.

Benzene, with its non-polar nature, can’t form hydrogen bonds with methanol. Instead, it disrupts the existing hydrogen bonds between methanol molecules. This disruption weakens the attractive forces between methanol molecules, making it easier for them to escape into the vapor phase.

Think of it like a group of people holding hands tightly. If you introduce someone who doesn’t want to hold hands, it weakens the bond between the original group, making it easier for some of them to break free.

This weaker interaction between benzene and methanol leads to a higher vapor pressure than expected for an ideal solution. This higher vapor pressure is a hallmark of a positive deviation from Raoult’s law.

Let’s dive into why ethanol and water mixtures show positive deviation from Raoult’s Law.

My teacher explained that for a solution to show positive deviation, it must have a compound that lacks hydrogen bonds and a compound that forms hydrogen bonds. This is because the compound without hydrogen bonds can disrupt the hydrogen bonds of the compound that does form them.

Now, let’s look at ethanol and water. Ethanol, C2H5OH, has a hydroxyl group, OH, which allows it to form hydrogen bonds with water molecules. However, ethanol also has a non-polar hydrocarbon chain, C2H5, which reduces its ability to form hydrogen bonds with other ethanol molecules.

This difference in hydrogen bonding ability between ethanol and water leads to a positive deviation from Raoult’s Law.

Here’s why:

Stronger interactions between water molecules: Water molecules form strong hydrogen bonds with each other. This strong interaction is disrupted when ethanol molecules are added. The ethanol molecules can’t form as many strong hydrogen bonds with water molecules, leading to weaker interactions in the mixture.
Weaker interactions between ethanol and water: Ethanol molecules, with their non-polar hydrocarbon chains, have weaker interactions with water molecules compared to the strong hydrogen bonding between water molecules.
Increased vapor pressure: Because the interactions between ethanol and water molecules are weaker than those between water molecules alone, the ethanol and water mixture has a higher vapor pressure than predicted by Raoult’s Law. This is because the molecules in the mixture escape into the gas phase more easily.

To summarize:

Ethanol and water mixtures show positive deviation from Raoult’s Law because of the weaker interactions between ethanol and water molecules compared to the strong interactions between water molecules. This leads to an increase in vapor pressure, resulting in a positive deviation.

Okay, let’s dive into what happens when a mixture has a positive deviation from Raoult’s law.

It’s important to remember that Raoult’s law describes the ideal behavior of mixtures, where the vapor pressure of each component is directly proportional to its mole fraction in the liquid phase. However, real-world mixtures often don’t behave perfectly, leading to deviations from this law.

When a mixture exhibits a positive deviation from Raoult’s law, the actual vapor pressure of the mixture is *higher* than what you’d expect from an ideal mixture. This means that the molecules in the mixture have a stronger tendency to escape into the vapor phase compared to if they were behaving ideally.

Think of it this way: imagine you have a mixture of two liquids, A and B. If the mixture exhibits a positive deviation, the molecules of A and B have a stronger attraction to each other than they do to their own kind. This means that the molecules of A and B are more likely to break free from the liquid phase and enter the vapor phase, leading to a higher vapor pressure.

Here’s a more visual way to understand this:

* In an ideal mixture, the vapor pressure of each component is proportional to its mole fraction in the liquid phase. This can be represented by a straight line on a graph.
* In a mixture with a positive deviation, the vapor pressure is higher than expected, resulting in a curve that *bends upwards* from the ideal straight line.

Let’s break down why this happens:

Intermolecular forces: The strength of intermolecular forces between the molecules of the different components in the mixture plays a crucial role. If the forces between unlike molecules (A-B) are weaker than the forces between like molecules (A-A or B-B), then the molecules have a stronger tendency to escape the liquid phase, leading to a higher vapor pressure.
Molecular size and shape: Differences in molecular size and shape can also contribute to deviations from Raoult’s law. For example, if the molecules of one component are significantly smaller than the molecules of the other component, the smaller molecules might escape the liquid phase more easily, resulting in a higher vapor pressure.
Non-ideal interactions: In some cases, there might be specific interactions between the molecules of the different components in the mixture that lead to deviations from Raoult’s law. These interactions could be things like hydrogen bonding or dipole-dipole interactions.

A few real-world examples of mixtures that exhibit positive deviations from Raoult’s law include:

Ethanol and water: The intermolecular forces between ethanol and water are weaker than those between ethanol molecules or water molecules, leading to a higher vapor pressure than expected.
Acetone and chloroform: These molecules have a tendency to form hydrogen bonds, leading to a higher vapor pressure than expected.

Understanding positive deviations from Raoult’s law is important in many areas of chemistry and engineering, particularly in distillation processes where the separation of different components is based on their vapor pressures.

Let’s talk about positive deviations from Raoult’s law. A solution exhibits a positive deviation when its vapor pressure is higher than what we’d expect based on Raoult’s law.

Think of it this way: Imagine you have a mixture of two liquids, A and B. If they were ideal, their vapor pressures would simply add up based on their individual amounts. However, in a positive deviation, the actual vapor pressure of the mixture is greater than this sum.

This happens because the interactions between the molecules of A and B are weaker than the interactions between the molecules of A with themselves or the molecules of B with themselves. In other words, the A-B interactions are weaker than the A-A or B-B interactions.

Here’s a simple analogy: Imagine two friends who are very close and love hanging out together. They’re like molecules of the same type, with strong interactions. Now, imagine these two friends are introduced to a third friend who’s a bit different. This third friend might not click as well with the first two. They’re like molecules of different types with weaker interactions.

This weaker interaction between the different types of molecules allows them to escape into the vapor phase more easily, leading to a higher vapor pressure.

Here are some key points to remember about positive deviations from Raoult’s law:

Weaker A-B interactions: The interactions between the components of the mixture are weaker than the interactions within the pure components.
Higher vapor pressure: The vapor pressure of the mixture is higher than predicted by Raoult’s law.
Lower boiling point: The boiling point of the mixture is lower than expected.
Positive enthalpy of mixing: This means that energy is absorbed when the components are mixed, indicating weaker interactions.

Examples of Positive Deviations:

Ethanol and Water: The mixture of ethanol and water shows a positive deviation. The hydrogen bonding between ethanol and water is weaker than the hydrogen bonding between ethanol molecules and water molecules.
Acetone and Carbon Disulfide: Acetone and carbon disulfide are also known to exhibit positive deviations due to the weak interactions between the molecules.

Positive deviations from Raoult’s law are a fascinating aspect of solution behavior and demonstrate the complex interplay of molecular interactions.

Let’s break down what causes a positive deviation from Raoult’s law.

Raoult’s law describes the vapor pressure of an ideal solution, where the components interact similarly. However, in real-world scenarios, things get a bit more complex. A positive deviation from Raoult’s law occurs when the partial vapor pressure of a component in a solution is higher than predicted by Raoult’s law. This means the molecules in the solution are more eager to escape into the vapor phase than they would be in an ideal situation.

Why does this happen? Think of it like this: Imagine the molecules of the solution are like people at a party. In an ideal solution, everyone gets along great – a-a and b-b interactions are strong, just like good friends hanging out. But in a real solution, sometimes there are people who don’t get along so well, like a-b interactions. These weaker interactions mean the molecules have less of a hold on each other, making them more likely to leave the liquid phase and become a vapor.

Think of it this way: Imagine a party where everyone is having a great time and bonding. They’re less likely to leave the party, just like molecules in an ideal solution are less likely to escape into the vapor phase. Now, picture a party where some people are arguing or not getting along. The atmosphere is less pleasant, and people are more likely to leave. This is similar to a solution with weaker a-b interactions, where molecules are more eager to escape into the vapor phase.

It’s important to remember that positive deviations are not always about molecules not getting along. Sometimes, it’s more about the molecules finding a greater sense of freedom in the vapor phase. Imagine a situation where two types of molecules are tightly packed in a liquid, like trying to squeeze too many people onto a dance floor. These molecules might be more inclined to escape into the vapor phase where they have more space and freedom to move around.

So, in summary, a positive deviation from Raoult’s law arises when the intermolecular interactions between different components in the solution are weaker than the interactions between the same types of molecules. This means that the molecules are more likely to escape into the vapor phase, resulting in a higher partial vapor pressure than predicted by Raoult’s law.

Why does ethanol and water mixture show positive deviation from

A positive deviation from Raoult’s law occurs when the partial vapor pressure is greater than would be expected from Raoult’s law. From a microscopic perspective, this implies that the a−b a − b interactions are weaker than the a−a a − a Chemistry Stack Exchange

NON-IDEAL MIXTURES OF LIQUIDS – chemguide

A large positive deviation from Raoult’s Law: ethanol and water mixtures. If you look back up the page, you will remember that a large positive deviation from Raoult’s Law produces a vapour pressure curve with a chemguide

Raoult’s Law and Ideal Mixtures of Liquids – Chemistry LibreTexts

2 of these are methanol. The mole fraction of methanol is 2/3. Similarly, the mole fraction of ethanol is 1/3. You can easily find the partial vapor pressures using Chemistry LibreTexts

Why ethanol & water show positive deviation. Explain in the point

Here, water forms hydrogen bonds of greater strength and magnitude than does methanol, and one expects that a water-methanol mixture will therefore possess weaker BYJU’S

Reason for the formation of azeotropes – Chemistry

A solution that shows positive deviation from Raoult’s law forms a minimum boiling azeotrope. A very well-known example would be the azetrope that forms from a ethanol and water mixture when it is Chemistry Stack Exchange

10.20: Ideal Solutions- Raoult’s Law – Chemistry

For non-ideal mixtures the actual vapor pressure can be larger than the ideal value (positive deviation from Raoult’s law) or smaller (negative deviation). Negative deviations correspond to cases where attractions Chemistry LibreTexts

the chemical mechanism for deviations from Raoult’s law

A positive deviation means that p is greater than expected from Raoult’s law and thus a negative deviation has pressure that is less than expected. Alcohol/water mixtures show positive deviations and Chemistry Stack Exchange

Change in Volume, H-Bonding (Ethanol and Water)

The volume deficit should be about 17.5 mL. If 95% ethanol is used, the shrinkage is still about 15 mL. The structure of liquid water is open because of hydrogen Chemistry LibreTexts

An aqueous solution of methanol in water has vapour pressure:

The solution will show positive deviation from Raoult’s law. Complete step by step answer: Deviation from Raoult’s law may either be positive deviation or a negative Vedantu